I would suggest you watch the game and mark on performance rather than have pre conceived ideas on players if you are going to mark them.
Everyone's favourite player to knock , Nyatanga played well and won most challenges - so why a 4 ?
Smiths kicking was appalling , so why mark him up ?
On the other hand , everyone's favourite JJOT was terrible . He was slow , gave the ball away and passed backwards most of the time . He was a 4 .
By the way , the crowd were a 1 / 10 - rubbish atmosphere and pursing all game by 150 Oldham.
P1ss poor all round
Nyatanga may have played well in general play but again, he failed to concentrate, anticipate and then deal with a basic cross across the 6 yard line which led to the opening goal.