You can forgive players with limited ability at L2 level, but you can't forgive lack of effort. I don't think Carter broke into a sweat yesterday - he offers nothing in defence or going forward because he covers so little ground. The only alternative to it being lack of effort is if he simply can't do it any more physically post-injury, in which case he needs a diffferent career.
Absolutely. The players must give 100% each and every game. I can't believe Carter was once a £1m+ player, he was cr@p on Saturday.