If you read through the posts you'd understand, all of them have failed time and time again. I would have expected you to disagree though as you don't have anything better to do.
Interesting that you'd keep Smith, Rose and Edmondson on. I assume your post is solely aimed at getting some much loved attention?
By your logic, BAS came from a Premier League club so he should also be kept on. Whilst we are at it, Warburton had reasonable success with his former club so we should also offer him a new deal as well.
Get rid of those 5 and get 2 competent strikers in, many of which will be available for free. Shop wisely, it's what Gillingham did and they've ended up with a 20+ goal a season striker at our expense.
So luck does not come into it?